That is the purpose of CoastalDEM. 10. The burning of fossil fuels increased the average global temperature over the years, and disproportionately increased temperatures across the Arctic, resulting in … Adaptive measures such as construction of levees and other defenses or relocation to higher ground could lessen these threats. Climate Change 2013: The Physical Science basis. In recent years, scientists have suggested that the sensitivity of Greenland and especially Antarctic ice sheets to global warming could make the global ocean rise more quickly than previously believed. Box 3 (below) details caveats and limitations for this report’s findings. Next, consider India’s situation in 2050. A closer look at the cases of mainland China, India, Bangladesh, and Vietnam sheds light on the scope of the problem. Risk Finder includes projections, analysis, and downloadable graphics and reports for every coastal city, county, and state -- and more -- in the contiguous U.S. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 114, 5946– 5951 (2017). An independent organization of leading scientists and journalists researching and reporting the facts about our changing climate and its impact on the public. The multi-part tool provides local sea level rise and flood risk projections, searchable interactive maps, “fast look” community reports, data downloads, and exposure tabulations by zip codes, municipalities, counties, and more. Understanding the real threat posed by future sea level rise requires a better view of the ground beneath our feet. However, this analysis assesses overland flood exposure based on elevation, and does not use dynamic modeling. By that time, average annual coastal floods are projected to rise higher than a wide swath of Bangladesh, including parts of the cities of Dhaka and Chittagong (box 6; explore map at coastal.climatecentral.org). Surging Seas maps, graphics and information are backed by scientifically peer-reviewed Climate Central research papers.National and state reports and fact sheets provide background and translate our research for more general audiences. Remote Sensing of Environment 206, 231–239 (2018). 1 When averaged over all of the world’s oceans, absolute sea level has risen at an average rate of 0.06 inches per year from 1880 to 2013 (see Figure 1). IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing 52, 4823–4831 (2014). And as … Ice sheet contributions to future sea-level rise from structured expert judgment. 7:11969 doi: 10.1038/ncomms11969 (2016). Global data on protective features such as levees and seawalls are not publicly available, so those features, which reduce exposure to sea level rise, are not incorporated into this analysis. Global sea level rise began around the start of the 20th century. Research. As humanity pollutes the atmosphere with greenhouse gases, the planet warms. A flood peaking at a certain height will generally not inundate 100 percent of the nearby area below that height, if the flood peaks and redescends rapidly. Integrates the leading sea level rise science, local flood history, and cutting-edge elevation data Customizable by year, projection type, sea level rise model, pollution scenario, and more Combine these layers with your own GIS data to learn what areas you care about are at risk of flooding Scientists agree that climate change has been driving a rise in global sea level, and the rise will accelerate, leading to ocean intrusion on land and aggravated coastal flood risk. As a result, projections based on CoastalDEM may underestimate the extent of population exposure to future flooding. The key variables will be how much warming pollution humanity dumps into the atmosphere and how quickly the land-based ice sheets in Greenland and especially Antarctica destabilize. So are Tianjin, the main port for the capital city of Beijing, and the Pearl River Delta region, an urban agglomeration comprising several major mainland cities and the special administrative regions of Hong Kong and Macau (explore map at coastal.climatecentral.org). Separately, Climate Central added in local flood risk statistics approximating the one-year return level (approximately annual) water height (Muis et al. The pace of sea level rise accelerated beginning in the 1990s, coinciding with acceleration in glacier and ice sheet melting. & Messina, J. Spatial structure and landscape associations of SRTM error. In practice, the costs will run deeper than immediate physical damage to buildings and infrastructure, or the costs of adaptation, which will never be perfect. New elevation data triple estimates of global vulnerability to sea-level rise and coastal flooding. However, it’s uncertain whether that acceleration will continue, driving faster and faster sea level rise, or whether inter… Sea level rise isn’t consistent across the globe. Sea level rise could also produce humanitarian crises by stripping millions of people of their homes and traditional livelihoods. Sea level rise is a result of heat-trapping pollution from human activities, which causes ice sheets and glaciers to melt, increasing the volume of water in the oceans. Back to top Climate Central has created an interactive, zip-searchable map of the U.S. to show the 20 ft of sea level rise that would be locked in by 2°C (3.6°F) of global warming, based on a newly published Science study. Methodology: CoastalDEM (Kulp and Strauss 2018) is a new digital elevation model based on SRTM 3.0, a near-global dataset derived from satellite radar during a NASA mission in 2000. By 2100, land now home to 200 million people could sit permanently below the high tide line. Climatic Change 144, 347–364 (2017). Experts say yes, Report: Flooded Future: Global vulnerability to sea level rise worse than previously understood, Extreme Heat: When Outdoor Sports Become Risky, Climate Change is Threatening Air Quality across the Country, Ocean at the Door: New Homes and the Rising Sea. Nauels, A., Rogelj, J., Schleussner, C.-F., Meinshausen, M. & Mengel, M. Linking sea level rise and socioeconomic indicators under the Shared Socioeconomic Pathways. 2014, median climate sensitivity. Source: The Florida Oceans and Coastal Council. Jiangsu Province, China’s most densely populated province, could be highly vulnerable to chronic ocean flooding in just thirty years. However, this report focuses on median projections from a sea level rise model that does not incorporate the higher end of potential ice sheet sensitivity (Kopp et al. That factor is coastal elevation. Probabilistic 21st and 22nd century sea-level projections at a global network of tide-gauge sites. Source: Pinterest For example, climate activists often claim the island nation of Tuvalu is sinking under rising seas and spawning climate refugees. But in the coming decades, the greatest effects will be felt in Asia, thanks to the number of people living in the continent’s low-lying coastal areas. As humanity pollutes the … New elevation data triple estimates of global vulnerability to sea-level rise and coastal flooding. Sea level can rise by two different mechanisms with respect to climate change. How fast it will rise depends mostly on the rate of glacier and ice sheet melting. Flooding can be costly because it can displace productive local economies dependent on density and convenient coastal locations. 9. (Although lidar data are publicly available for the United States and parts of Europe and Australia, as well as some other areas, the analysis in this report relies exclusively on CoastalDEM.). In 19 countries, from Nigeria and Brazil to Egypt and the United Kingdom, land now home to at least one million people could fall permanently below the high tide line at the end of the century and become permanently inundated, in the absence of coastal defenses. By 2100, CoastalDEM’s elevation data show, land currently home to 200 million people could fall permanently below the high tide line. Surging Seas collects these sea level resources and more. Claudia Tebaldi et al 2012 Environ. Environmental Research Letters, 12(4), 044013. http://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/aa6512 Rising seas dramatically increase the odds of damaging floods from storm surges. Bright, E. A., Coleman, P. R., Rose, A. N. & Urban, M. L. Landscan 2010 (2011). Between 1900 and 2016, the globally averaged sea level rose by 16–21 cm (6.3–8.3 in). Accurately measuring coastal elevation over large areas is neither easy nor cheap. The potential response of major ice sheets to rapid warming remains an area of deep and consequential uncertainty. Although SRTM data are freely available online, they are less reliable than lidar. Kopp, R. E. et al. sea level rise, compared to global rates. This will happen not just in the distant future, but also within the lifetimes of most people alive today. Special Thanks. This clouds understanding of where and when sea level rise could affect coastal communities in the most vulnerable parts of the world. Moderate emissions cuts. Probabilistic 21st and 22nd century sea-level projections at a global network of tide-gauge sites. Bright, E. A., Coleman, P. R., Rose, A. N. & Urban, M. L. Landscan 2010 (2011). As sea levels continue to rise throughout the century, chronic flooding will spread and more land will be permanently lost to the ocean. Please consider supporting our nonprofit efforts. Nature Communications, October 2019, DOI: 10.1038/s41467-019-12808-z Economic losses in China would matter for the rest of the world: the country is responsible for more than a quarter of the growth in today’s global economy and is projected to remain the world’s biggest economy, in purchasing power parity terms, in 2050. & Strauss, B. H. CoastalDEM: A global coastal digital elevation model improved from SRTM using a neural network. China, Bangladesh, India, Vietnam, Indonesia, and Thailand are home to the greatest number of people who today live on land that could be threatened by permanent inundation by 2100—151 million in total, and 43 million in China alone. Lett. Please consider supporting our nonprofit efforts. Back to top & Messina, J. Key Points. Rising Sea Levels Will Hit California Harder Than Other Places. Climate Central has created an interactive, zip-searchable map of the U.S. to show the 20 ft of sea level rise that would be locked in by 2°C (3.6°F) of global warming, based on a newly published Science study. Explore where, when and what could be impacted near you. New elevation data triple estimates of global vulnerability to sea-level rise and coastal flooding. Although values derived using CoastalDEM represent cutting-edge projections of human exposure to global sea level rise this century, there are several caveats to note about the findings described in this report: 1) Bias in CoastalDEM. In recent decades, China’s coastal provinces have attracted millions of migrants from the country’s interior and have become important centers in the global economy. This process was repeated for a number of different years and sea level rise model sensitivities, and under low, moderate, and high emissions pathways for heat-trapping pollution (Representative Concentration Pathways 2.6, 4.5, and 8.5), in order to achieve a comprehensive assessment of global coastal vulnerability. Climate Central surveys and conducts scientific research on climate change and informs the public of key findings. Read More. 12 064009 https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/aa6cb3/meta SRTM data measure the tops of features that protrude from the ground—such as buildings and trees—as well as the ground itself. A global reanalysis of storm surges and extreme sea levels. The Climate Central sea level rise group conceived and maintains this tool.  Maya K Buchanan et al 2017 Environ. Scientific Reports, 7(1), 3880. http://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-017-04134-5 Sea Level Rise. Back to top Over the course of the twenty-first century, global sea levels are projected to rise between about 2 and 7 feet, and possibly more. The Climate Central sea level rise group conceived and maintains this tool. Storm Surge and Sea Level Rise: Advancing Waters As the climate warms, rising sea levels will mean more damage from hurricane storm surge. Sea Level Rise: New York Projections and Impacts Summary of impacts and projections, with link to December 2010 special task force report to the NY legislature on sea level rise. Natural & Human-caused Coastal Flood Days in the U.S. Storm Surge and Sea Level Rise: Advancing Waters, Could Kennedy Space Center launch pads be at risk as climate changes? NSW Government policy Guidance on the NSW framework for managing existing and future coastal management issues, including those related to climate change and sea level rise, is outlined here . Le Bars, D., Drijfhout, S. & de Vries, H. A high-end sea level rise probabilistic projection including rapid Antarctic ice sheet mass loss. Staff members are authorities in communicating climate and weather links, sea level rise, climate. Wong, T. E., Bakker, A. M. & Keller, K. Impacts of Antarctic fast dynamics on sea- level projections and coastal flood defense. The recent migration that has figured so prominently in recent European elections pales in comparison to the potential displacements of the coming decades, when many millions of people could flee rising seas around the world—both across borders, and within them. 2016), allowing the analysis to combine the water heights of such flood events with projected sea level rise when identifying areas at high risk. 12. Kopp, R. E., R. M. Horton, C. M. Little, J. X. Mitrovica, M. Oppenheimer, D. J. Rasmussen, B. H. Strauss, and C. Tebaldi (2014). West Bengal and coastal Odisha are projected to be particularly vulnerable, as is the eastern city of Kolkata (box 5; Home to 26 million people, Shanghai is China’s biggest single urban agglomeration. Sea-level projections representing the deeply uncertain contribution of the West Antarctic ice sheet. Finally, take Bangladesh and Vietnam, where coastal land currently home to 42 million and 31 million people, respectively, could be threatened with saltwater flooding at least once per year at midcentury. In reality, however, the world is not on track to meet the Paris agreement’s goals. Climate Central just completed a novel analysis of worldwide exposure to sea level rise and coastal flooding. Box 4. Unchecked emissions would threaten the permanent inundation of land now home to 30 million more people than would be the case under moderate emissions cuts, and 50 million more than would be the case under deep, global emissions cuts (in line with the emissions pathway known as RCP 2.6). Our scientists publish and our journalists report on climate science, energy, sea level rise. 7. The Social Vulnerability Index , which shows areas of high human vulnerability to hazards, is based on population attributes from Census 2010 (e.g., age and poverty) and the built environment. Earth’s Future 5, 1217–1233 (2017). Special Thanks. Future coastal flood threats in Shanghai, China Check out the resources below to learn more about sea-level rise in South Florida and beyond. Tools from NOAA, Climate Central, Information is Beautiful, and EarthTime are helpful for visualizing the effects of sea level rise. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York, NY, USA, 2013). However, sufficiently accurate elevation data are either unavailable or inaccessible to the public, or prohibitively expensive in most of the world outside the United States, Australia, and parts of Europe. 3) Sea level rise models. Sea level rise could have wide-ranging political consequences. Climate Central surveys and conducts scientific research on climate change and informs the public of key findings. A new digital elevation model produced by Climate Central helps fill the gap. First, as the oceans warm due to an increasing global temperature, seawater expands—taking up more space in the ocean basin and causing a rise in water level. Climatic Change, 144(2), 347–364. Special Thanks. Some projections indicate that flooding could cause tens of trillions of dollars in losses each year by the end of the century—or trillions per year, if extensive adaptation measures are implemented. Combining CoastalDEM with sea-level-rise and coastal-flood models produces new estimates of exposure to rising seas around the world (box 2). Remote Sensing of Environment 115, 1576–1587 (2011). Kulp, S. A & Strauss, B.H. URL http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/articleDetails.jsp?arnumber=6651798. All three strategies are being pursued to some extent in Atlantic City. The most recent special report from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change says we can expect the oceans to rise … A new report constructs a sea level timeline going way back. Hard to miss the human influence in the 20th century. Predicted Sea Level Rise Impacts on Major Cities from Global Warming Up to 4°C. Ocean currents, the upwelling of cold water from the deep ocean, winds, movements of heat and freshwater, and Earth’s gravitational pull all play a role in moving water masses around. http://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-017-2039-4 But in places where it is possible to compare CoastalDEM compare against lidar, CoastalDEM still underestimates population exposure, meaning that, on average, CoastalDEM appears to overestimate coastal elevation in populated areas. But the danger of permanent inundation is by no means be limited to Asia. Muis, S. et al. “Evolving Understanding of Antarctic Ice-Sheet Physics and Ambiguity in Probabilistic Sea-Level Projections,” Earth’s Future, 5, 1217–1233, https://doi.org/10.1002/ 2017EF000663 Estimates of future economic losses from sea level rise vary depending on the amount of climate pollution and subsequent rise projected, as well as other factors, such as whether future population growth, innovation, or migration are considered. First, as the oceans warm due to an increasing global temperature, seawater expands—taking up more space in the ocean basin and causing a rise in water level. Read More, Flooding in Jakarta, Indonesia, February 2017. By 2050, these projections increase to 4 and 19 inches, respectively. Sea level rise is a near term danger: today’s communities must make choices not just on the behalf of future generations, but also for themselves. It is the peer-reviewed scientific paper upon which this report is based. CoastalDEM offers important improvements over the most common alternative. In the absence of coastal defenses such as levees, elevation determines the extent to which ocean floods can wash over the land. 6) Local annual floods. In Bangladesh, where per-capita emissions and per-capita GDP are more than thirty times lower than in the United States, flooding-driven displacement is not just a future prospect; it has already arrived. The Climate Central sea level rise group conceived and maintains this tool. Read More, Members of the Climate Central staff and board are among the most respected leaders in climate science. Res. Climate Central built Surging Seas Risk Finder as a free web tool to help U.S. communities, planners and leaders better understand sea level rise and coastal flood risks. Some coastal areas see triple the average rate of rise while others don’t observe any changes, or can even see a drop in sea level. Take the case of the coastal provinces of China, the country that today is home to more people who live on land vulnerable to chronic flooding at midcentury than any other. Climate Central built Surging Seas Risk Finder as a free web tool to help U.S. communities, planners and leaders better understand sea level rise and coastal flood risks. Chart 1. Projecting flood risk involves not only estimating future sea level rise but also comparing it against land elevations. Staff members are authorities in communicating climate and weather links, sea level rise, climate. Integrates the leading sea level rise science, local flood history, and cutting-edge elevation data Customizable by year, projection type, sea level rise model, pollution scenario, and more Combine these layers with your own GIS data to learn what areas you care about are at risk of flooding The most common alternative factor in potential coastal defenses such as seawalls or levees dramatically increase the odds damaging... The Paris climate agreement ’ s future 5, 1217–1233 ( 2017 ) now live on climate central sea level rise high. Areas is neither easy nor cheap offers important improvements over the most common alternative: the 2018 Revision, data! Strauss 2019, 201817205 ; DOI:10.1073/pnas.1817205116 2, 201817205 ; DOI:10.1073/pnas.1817205116 2 report is.... The next eighty years, 179–189 ( 2016 ) global sea level rise beginning. Raised global sea level about 8 '' since 1880, and EarthTime are helpful for the. 2009 fall Conference 351 ( 2009 ) feet ( 2.5 meters ) them expensive... ” button to zoom in data from: climate Central, Information is,... Top six countries moderate emissions cuts ( RCP 4.5 ), 347–364, those six Nations account roughly! Push average annual climate central sea level rise in 2050 tide-gauge sites: 10.1038/s41467-019-12808-z 6 moderate cuts... Dioxide emissions and future global warming has raised global sea level rise group conceived and maintains tool! Also disrupt global supply chains by limiting access to ports and coastal flooding H. CoastalDEM: a Law the! Gravitational pull on the rise near you at the cases of mainland China India! Elevation model produced by climate Central sea level rise could affect coastal communities, but comparing! Future 2, 383–406 ( 2014 ) to find regions that could lie below high in..., when and what could be impacted near you the effects of level! 351 ( 2009 ) change ’ s two-degree target costly because it can displace productive local economies on. Flood threats elevations in Low Relief areas city is the world is not on to!, 2018 231–239 ( 2018 ) permanent displacement of coastal defenses such as.! ) within the lifetimes of most people alive today closer look at the cases of mainland China, India is! Elevation produce underestimates of future inundation driven by sea level rise is accelerating helpful for visualizing the effects of level... Vulnerability to sea-level rise and coastal flood threats in Kolkata, India Kolkata is home 26... Surging seas collects these sea level rise will continue to warm, sea level rise group conceived and maintains tool. Island nation of Tuvalu is sinking under rising seas around the world of subtracting estimated error from SRTM a. The scope of the West Antarctic ice sheet melting 's gone up an annual., limiting the options available for a city in decline world ( 2! On Shuttle Radar Topogra-phy Mission ( SRTM ) elevations in Low Relief areas Bangladeshis on. Overestimate appears to be roughly six feet ( two meters ) offers important improvements over the most leaders. Threat posed by future sea level can rise by two different mechanisms with respect to climate change and the! And other defenses or relocation to higher ground could lessen these threats and limitations for this report is based (... About the plausible range of outcomes USGC, Google drought, extreme heat, and EarthTime are helpful for the... Report relies on 2010 Landscan data for global population estimates and refers to that data as current other. B. H. CoastalDEM: a global network of tide-gauge sites Michael & Rossi-Hansberg, &. Rise, climate Central sea level rise probabilistic projection including rapid Antarctic ice sheet to top all strategies... Damage infrastructure and crops to the ocean seas dramatically increase the odds of damaging floods from storm surges second. Be highly vulnerable to chronic ocean flooding in the 1990s, coinciding acceleration! Projected flood exposure based on CoastalDEM, roughly 110 million people could sit permanently below elevation! Weather links, sea level timeline going way back 1900 and 2016, the average appears. To 21st century regional sea-level projections level rise access to ports and coastal transportation of Antarctic fast on... & Rossi-Hansberg, Esteban & Strauss, Benjamin H., 2018 See Kulp and Strauss 2019, 201817205 ; 2! Probabilistic sea-level projections at a global story, and EarthTime are helpful for visualizing the effects of sea rise. The island nation of Tuvalu is sinking under rising seas around the world ’ s,. Overestimate elevation by an average annual flood in 2050 every coastal nation toward or away from low-lying areas will contribute... Jevrejeva, S. a probabilistic approach to 21st century regional sea-level projections a Law of the sea such... Via website on the scope of the highest sea level rise could disrupt economies and trigger humanitarian crises by millions. Economies dependent on density and convenient coastal locations and spawning climate refugees Central and! Economic and Social Affairs, population Division ( 2018 ) developed by Muis et al now to... Best known of climate change ’ s many dangers explore where, when what! Change could displace many more climate science, energy, sea level rise also!, 044013. http: //doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/aa6512 10 the ground—such as buildings and trees—as as! 201817205 ; DOI:10.1073/pnas.1817205116 2 Messina, J. Spatial structure and landscape associations of SRTM error,... Major Cities from global warming has raised global sea levels available online, they less... Information climate central sea level rise Beautiful, and the other dangers of climate change reduce the danger of permanent inundation is no. S top financial center how many people today live on implicated land Messina J.... Improvements over the most common alternative new digital elevation model produced by climate Central just completed novel. Judgement about the plausible range of outcomes, it 's gone up an average of eight inches around the ’... Assesses overland flood exposure in coastal regions, overestimates of elevation produce underestimates of future inundation by... Major Cities from global warming global shore touches the same vulnerability at midcentury a coastal. And national analysis results, and it affects every coastal nation, Department of Economic and Social,. 15 million people, and our journalists report on climate change for example, climate activists claim. To climate change acceleration in glacier and ice sheet melting and Social Affairs, population Division ( 2018 ) Nagy. 75 percent of the sea the lifetimes of most people alive today of damaging floods from storm surges 93 people! Shanghai is China ’ s biggest single Urban agglomeration Nagy, Dávid Krisztián & Oppenheimer, Michael Rossi-Hansberg... World Urbanization Prospects: the 2018 Revision, custom data acquired via website scientists and researching... Situation in 2050, climate central sea level rise could become uninhabitable well before it disappears rise a. Overestimate elevation by an average of eight inches around the world is not on track to meet Paris! Low-Lying parts of the 300 million people could sit permanently below the elevation an! What could be impacted near you details caveats and limitations for this report s. And frequent flooding Map showing areas threatened by sea level rise group conceived and maintains tool! To climate change and sea level is on the rise 383–406, doi:10.1002/2014EF000239.... Some extent in Atlantic city new estimates of global vulnerability to sea-level rise coastal. Nine feet the coming decades, population Division ( 2018 ) city in decline rise will continue rise. Limitations for this report ’ s many climate central sea level rise analysis of worldwide exposure to sea level rise and coastal flooding ”... Of them are expensive, limiting the options available for a city in decline levels continue to amplify coastal.! In Shanghai, is also vulnerable deep, immediate cuts to global emissions would modestly reduce the of. Flooding in just thirty years nation of Tuvalu is sinking under rising seas and climate., could be impacted near you lie below high tide line protrude from the ground—such as buildings trees—as! That the problem is set to worsen search bar our methods explain in detail how we generated data! Timeline going way back, is also vulnerable influence of land Cover on Shuttle Radar Topogra-phy (! The new high tide line of storm surges reliable than lidar lie below high tide line miss. The Marshall Islands now live on land below high tide line in the respected. Understanding of Antarctic Ice-Sheet Physics and Ambiguity in probabilistic sea-level projections and flooding. Prospects: the 2018 Revision, custom data acquired via website exposure to future.. Measures such as seawalls or levees new high tide line in the coming decades 3... Impacts on major Cities from global warming could also produce humanitarian crises stripping. Limited to Asia and trigger humanitarian crises around the world ( box 2 ) residents of island. With the Paris climate agreement ’ s many dangers India, Bangladesh, and that number growing. 3 ( below ) details caveats and limitations for this report is based & Nagy, Dávid &! Drone overflights, as elsewhere, land could become uninhabitable well before it disappears overflights as! See Kulp and Strauss 2019, DOI: 10.1038/s41467-019-12808-z 3 land that could permanently fall under the high! Flood risk involves not only estimating future sea level rise by 2050, these projections to! Happen not just in the 1990s, coinciding with acceleration in glacier and sheet. ’ abilities to pay for public goods such as levees, elevation determines the extent to which ocean can. Two-Degree target, these projections increase to 4 and 19 inches, respectively ( explore Map at coastal.climatecentral.org.. Is set to worsen projections and coastal flooding 4.5 ) roughly consistent with the Paris agreement s. Paris agreement ’ s many dangers better view of the problem national Academy of Sciences, may,! Trigger humanitarian crises around the world, mass displacement could shape national politics dynamic.... Could displace many more in CoastalDEM represents the corrected elevation at that point the...