Perhaps you'd be better off trying some poultry fat (duck, chicken, goose) in a smaller batch that's easier and quicker to do. Torches are candles on poles that are carried in the processional and used to flank the reading of the Gospel. As a result, they burned the bayberry candles only on special occasions like Christmas and New Year’s Eve. Lamps and candles were in normal use in Christian worship by the 4th century, but for many years it was not customary to place candles on the altar. The solid fat burns about 8-10 hour for each candle, making them a long lasting item in our storm preps. Today, tallow candles are still made from “rendered” sheep or beef fat from around the cow’s kidneys, so little wonder they can go rancid, can cause irritations in sensitive people, and smell awful once you know exactly what it is your nose is picking up! Here’s why to avoid it: Whether we are stealing honey, royal jelly, pollen, propolis, or wax from bees, these incredible little insects-capable of complicated communication documented in their dances and of a social network compared to which our most carefully designed modern communities pale, suffer and die quite needlessly. Homemade Tallow Candles won’t give you cancer and they can provide you with the aromatherapy of your choice! Never leave a burning candle unattended. Wicks consist of a bundle of fibers that are twisted, braided, or knitted together. anon144171 January 19, 2011 . These candles smelled much better and didn’t smoke like the tallow ones. Tallow is naturally pretty fragrant, though I don't consider the smell unpleasant. Around the 12th century the custom began of inscribing the current year on the candle as well as the dates of the movable feasts. Sourcing Beef Tallow Before you run out to your local butcher shop to buy what they have on hand, consider this: An analysis found that tallow obtained from grass-fed beef had four times more omega 3 fatty acids than grain fed. It provides little skin conditioning, but adds to the mildness and hardness of the soap. I’m not a fan of the way tallow smells while burning so I personally wouldn’t use it unless I was making candles to for emergencies such as power outages. Extend a taper one inch before lighting and trim after extinguishing. Around this time cotton and linen came into the market and both were used for wicks. C ombing beeswax and lard (or tallow) gives me a wax that's not too hard for containers and smells sweet like honey so there is no need for fragrance oils. (EPA warns of the health hazards of burning paraffin candles.) Did you know that the waxes and scents found in many candles are carcinogens? Offer to give a lesson in lighting and snuffing to the acolytes! I had read about folks making candles with lard and tallow but both fats are pretty soft and don't smell all that great. What harmful products are often used in candles? At the order of Worship for the Evening, the lighting of the altar candles and other candles follows the Prayer for Light and precedes the hymn “O Gracious Light.”. I'm 60 years old and have never seen or smelled a tallow candle. But, best of all, they are a high-quality candle that has been made for generations and that you can make at home using items that could otherwise go to waste. The snuffer helps prevent wax sprays and keeps the wick centered. The early candles in America were made by suspending wicks in a mold and pouring liquid tallow three times and then hanging on a rack to dry. Candles are often used as a sign of festivity and solemnity in Christian worship. Advent wreath — An advent wreath is a circle of greenery with four candles of color, which may be purple or Sarum blue, and rose. Originally, candles were made from tallow, which was extracted from cattle and sheep, in the early Egyptian and Roman times. Stir vigorously. By 1415, tallow candles were used in street lighting. Stearic acid became and still is today a vital part of the candle industry. They are no longer made from animal tallow, instead opting for a 100% soy wax recipe. The first patented candle making machines were introduced. Using a candle of your choosing, let it burn for several minutes or until about an inch-deep pool of melted wax has accumulated around the wick. In early China and Japan tapers were made with wax from insects and seeds wrapped in rice paper. A fine alternative to animal tallow is vegetable tallow, a substance resembling tallow, obtained from various plants. Keep out of reach of children and pets. Never allow the snuffer to rest on the follower when extinguishing the flame as the follower is resting on both liquid and soft wax. And while little is known of the origins, we do know that Egyptians and Romans were dipping reeds and papyrus in animal fats to light their way. Once this happens, place the scented wax cube into the melted wax. • Petroleum smoke/exhaust contains many carcinogenic toxins and produces ugly black soot • Petroleum is not a renewable resource and it is of a limited supply • Burning petroleum products creates air pollution and contributes to global warming. Instead of beeswax-coated wicks, you can also buy paper, hemp and cotton wicks. These candles smelled much better and didn’t smoke like the tallow ones. I love ’em and when dh gets another deer (we’ve had a few sparse seasons), I claim the tallow…. Accounts of candle use date back to ancient times with Biblical references as early as the 10th century BC. In this post, you will learn the benefits of beef tallows, how to render tallow, and its substitute. anon144171 January 19, 2011 . After this first dipping, the candles would be dipped repeatedly until they were thick enough. Keep out of drafts. anon258866 April 3, 2012 . They may be placed near the altar and lighted during services. The main ingredients to avoid are beeswax, which is stolen from the industrious bees’ hive, tallow (a slaughterhouse product), and paraffin wax, a petroleum product that is associated with health risks. This is an optional practice that is decided by the Rector or the Vicar. Except when that candle is actually filling your home with toxic chemicals and contributing to indoor air pollution. Soy candles, made from American grown soybeans, last 50% longer than petroleum based (paraffin) candles and are biodegradable. Tallow has historically been abundant and cheap, making it the fat best known for being used to make soap and candles, as well as for cooking and frying. Some of these did have a smell, but it was the scent of animal fat (tallow) instead of a Mother’s Day garden. They don't stink like some people say if the wax is rendered properly and very clean but they do have a different odor. I’m happy to report that the candles burn beautifully, do NOT smell like burning fat, and they last a long time. Tallow is a nice, hard fat that holds it shape well, and works great for candle making. What is the density of liquid tallow at 60 degrees Celsius? No BLOWING. Combing beeswax and lard (or tallow) gives me a wax that's not too hard for containers and smells sweet like honey so there is no need for fragrance oils. This is why candles made from beeswax were used for church and royal events. By the 13th Century, the art of candling was embraced in England and France. It's smell, just like it's colour, is dependent upon what the bees who made the wax were feeding on at the time the wax was harvested from the hive. Yak butter was used for candles in Tibet and in India wax was made from boiling the fruit of the cinnamon tree. Sheep fat is hard, but cow fat is harder. Perfume was put in the melt pool to try to mask the smell. What is the density of liquid tallow at 60 degrees Celsius? Woman and dog: © iStock.com/adogslifephoto Dog: © iStock.com/timsa, Current subscribers: You will continue to receive e-mail unless you explicitly opt out by clicking, Selecting Candles Without Tallow, Paraffin, or Beeswax, 5 Ways PETA Is Helping Animals in Laboratories This Week, Exploitation to Innovation: ‘Animalkind’ on the Evolution of Science, Over 100 Animals Rescued From Taal Volcano: See Them Now. They are less expensive than pure beeswax although they burn faster. Bee farmers then remove the honey and the honeycomb, which is, of course, the hive’s main source of nourishment, and replace it with cheap white sugar. “So, not only is beef tallow great for cooking, but it was the original candle.” Beeswax is very expensive, and paraffin is a petroleum product—and neither was available to the average Joe living, say, 500 years ago. Tallow chandlery was often a side business of butchers. Trim the wick of any candle to ¼ inch every time you light the candle. The Roman Empire was the first to provide evidence of a candle that resembles the candle today. Tallow candles would be perfectly legal, but there are other issues here. The wick does not burn but feeds the oil for a flame thus needs no trimming. The first candle mould comes from 15th century Paris. Tallow candles vary in their hardness, depending on the animal the fat came from. Straighten the wick and precondition the candle by burning for at least two minutes. Yes, the process of making your own candles is quite simple and very enjoyable. According to the National Candle Association, candles have been used as far back as 5,000 years ago as a source of light. The name candle comes from the Latin candere meaning “to shine.” While no date can be definitely pinned down for the development of the first candle, we do know that candles were developed independently in many countries. Tallow from cows and sheep became the standard material used in candles in Europe. Although beef tallow can be pretty stinky when you are rendering it, thankfully, I haven’t noticed any smell when I burn my tallow candles. Beeswax candles are expensive but at the same time are economical as they burns slowly, are odorless, dripless, and smokeless. Alum is available at a local pharmacy. I had read about folks making candles with lard and tallow but both fats are pretty soft and don't smell all that great. “That’s where the candle idea came from. Tallow candles will also give off this smell and may be best suited for burning outdoors or in well ventilated areas. This practice was later transferred to the following Sunday. Tallow retained much of the smell of the animal both during the production of the candle and when it was burned, so tallow was considered less desirable than beeswax as candle-making material. How it can be removed? In a small home the fire in the hearth was often a major source of light, but you could brighten up different areas, and even have a light you could carry from place to place if you had a candle in a portable holder. Deer, goat, and elk fats make the hardest tallow and are ideal for candle making. It is an oil filled case with a fiberglass wick that is attached to your lighter after all of the taper has been removed. Candles. ... Whatever the reason, it has ruled out dinner plates as the destiny of the tallow. anon258866 April 3, 2012 . Beeswax candles were widely used for church ceremonies. A fairly new adapter for the lighter has been developed and marketed by Almy. Brass or glass candle FOLLOWERS should be placed on altar candles to ensure even burning. They had no smell, burned the brightest of all the candles in the house, and were absolutely a breeze to make. It was a tedious task and the popularity soon faded, as it required 1 and ½ quarts of berries to make an 8-inch taper. The Egyptians and Cretans made candles from beeswax as early as 3000 BC. If you hold a hand rolled candle up to your nose and breathe in, each candle smells similar, but if you have candles from different batches of beeswax, a good nose can detect subtle differences. Candles – Traditionally, people used tallow to make candles quite often. Most of the candles we reviewed burn for longer than 30 hours, making them an enduring addition to … It could be pale creamy fat, not too smelly when the candle was alight, or full of impurities. I addressed these very questions in a chapter in one of my books, Making Kind Choices: Shopping for candles, whether to light the table for that special romantic evening, votive candles to float in the bath, or ones to pop in the kitchen drawer just in case the lights go out, means thinking about what goes into them. Tallow Soap Doesn’t Smell. anon68756 March 4, 2010 . We had some free time and we just played around with it. The only drawback is that it is oil from paraffin, which is petroleum based. Beef tallow uses around the house, workshop, and homestead. If you were making the candles yourself, you needed a pan of hot tallow. Beware that rendering fat will fill the house with the smell of roasting meat, some find the smell nauseating. Discontinue use when only 1/2 in. So if you are sensitive to smells you may want to do this in an outdoor kitchen. Today’s smaller size is more suitable for carrying to the altar in procession at the Easter Vigil. You can still do that today! The whaling industry brought the first major change in candle making in the late 18th century with spermaceti, a wax obtained by crystallizing sperm whale oil. Whether beef tallow will smell or not really depends on how it is rendered. Initially it was broken up after the Easter Vigil and its fragments given to the faithful. For this reason, sweet-smelling beeswax was game changing in the world of candles, and a welcome alternative to stinky Tallow! You can also add essential oils to the candles to make aromatherapy candles, or mosquito reducing candles. A tricky job! The unpleasant smell of tallow candles is due to the glycerine they contain. The unpleasant smell of tallow candles is … Fortunately, you can manipulate the hardness of the tallow by adding alum or stearic acid. Perhaps you'd be better off trying some poultry fat (duck, chicken, goose) in a smaller batch that's easier and quicker to do. How it can be removed? The type of wax used in a candle determines the type of wick. The black smoke that a paraffin candle emits is basically diesel exhaust and as it is oil instead of water based, it is harder to clean up. This same process for making hand dipped tallow candles can be used with paraffin wax as well. This is the hard pale fat from cows or sheep, and it was available in different qualities according to how much it had been processed by the tallow boiler. No one really knows when the first candle was invented, but in Roman times candles were made of the pith of certain rushes, peeled except on one side, and dipped in animal fat, so animal fat was always a factor. Tallow is naturally pretty fragrant, though I don't consider the smell unpleasant. By being melted over and refined it acquires a fine and transparent green color. First, render the fat down. The wick draws the liquefied wax up into the flame to burn. It is important for followers to be cleaned between uses either placing them in boiling water or in a freezer for easy removal of wax. Always use a snuffer to extinguish a candle. Through a volcanic eruption and a global pandemic, PETA Asia came to the aid of countless animals and found loving... PETA is a nonprofit, tax-exempt 501(c)(3) corporation (tax ID number 52-1218336). The use of such lights has a long and varied tradition. Fat from goats, sheep, llamas, alpacas, deer, moose, elk, caribou and other ungulates is hard and when rendered is called tallow. Some tallow smells really bad – especially if it isn’t rendered completely or has become contaminated by moisture – while other tallow has hardly any smell at all. Once any fat is scorched, it's not going to end up being very good, unfortunately. Moving the snuffer too fast after extinguishing the flame will cause wax to drip. Tallow Soap Doesn’t Smell. The first known mention of the use of altar lights was a 12th century report that two candles flanked an altar cross in the papal chapel. But, they couldn’t create many of them because they needed to boil 15 pounds of bayberries to get one pound of wax. Today, tallow candles are still made from “rendered” sheep or beef fat from around the cow’s kidneys, so little wonder they can go rancid, can cause irritations in sensitive people, and smell awful once you know exactly what it is your nose is picking up! Sheep fat is hard, but cow fat is harder. In Asia, candles were made from insects and tree nuts. Like beeswax it did not smell bad and actually was found to be harder than tallow and beeswax. Immediately extend the taper out from the tube to avoid wax build up and jamming. A votive light is a small candle often used at the Festival of Lessons and Carols and at the Feast of the Epiphany service on January 6, celebrating the coming of the Magi. Paraffin candles are not recommended because they are made from petroleum sludge, highly refined and treated with carcinogenic chemicals. The smell of the manufacturing process was so unpleasant that it was banned by ordnance in several cities. The use of candles at the Eucharist was disputed in the Church of England and in the Episcopal Church during the 19th Century. It is the best method for how to render and purify tallow for soap, tallow balm, or candles. However, it took an entire honeycomb's worth of beeswax to make one 4" candle, so it was very expensive. candles and winter skin salve… what a great thing to use! A white candle in the center, called the Christ Candle is lighted on Christmas Eve. To change the future, you need to know the past. Always use a follower on altar candles. After snuffing the candles and retracting the taper in the lighter tube. Of course, neither is necessary as tallow candles burn cleanly and have no smell. By submitting this form, you are agreeing to our collection, storage, use, and disclosure of your personal info in accordance with our privacy policy as well as to receiving e-mails from us. Tallow, beeswax, and vegetable wax such as bayberry in North American, candleberry in the East, and waxberry in South America, were later supplemented by whale oil (spermaceti) and by stearine or stearic acid in the early 1800s (this is still obtained from plants which process the carcasses of dogs and cats killed in animal pounds and shelters), then by paraffin in the mid-1800s. Some tallow chandlers also produced soaps. The candle grew in size and in some cases weighed 300 lbs. Once placed on a candle, a follower should not be removed until the candle is ready for disposing. As a result, they burned the bayberry candles only on special occasions like Christmas and New Year’s Eve. It turns out so beautifully. Personally, I save the FOs for my paraffin candles as my tallow candles are used primarily for emergency situations when our power is out. Next, a “bee brush” is used to crudely sweep away the bees who rush from the hive and succumb to the smoke. You can also add color chips to produce colored candles and essential oils and other scents to produce scented candles to the melted tallow. INGREDIENTS: These natural candles are made with 100% local ingredients of local grassfed tallow and local raw beeswax. Interestingly the middle class would according to my research, often mix a little beeswax into their lamb tallow at about a 3/4 tallow, 1/4 beeswax, this would produce a slightly firmer candle and would create a more pleasent smell when burning. The purpose of a wick is to deliver fuel (wax) to the flame. Deer, goat, and elk fats make the hardest tallow and are ideal for candle making. Pieces of wick (if it has not been trimmed to ¼ inch) can fall and burn linens. Makes a smoky candle. Which made me consider candles, way back in December. You can still do that today! Do not move candle while burning or if wax is hot. Pavement Lights are candles in long holders or poles in stands that rest on the floor of the church. You can use any animal fat with this, from beef tallow to deer tallow. From this tallow they make candles in many parts of this province, but they usually mix some common tallow with it. However the candles had a very unpleasant smell due to the glycerin content. In these examples, I have natural tallow and goat milk soap for moisturizing, and the brown soap pictured below has coffee grounds added to it for a sweet smell and added scrubbing texture for a wake up revitalizing soap, and the orange is mango, fruit and citrus scents. In fact, it was so bad that several towns banned their use by ordinance. The following recipe for handmade tallow candles is from the 17th century: To make tallow candles, take 1 Zentner (German hundredweight) tallow, 1/2 Pfund (German pound) bone glue, 2 chamber pots urine and 1 Kandel (bucket) vinegar (Georgica Curiosa, 1695). Tallow is semi-soft beef fat that’s great for high heat frying as it remains very stable under hot temperature and imparts a good flavor. Beef fat emits a foul smell. If placed on the altar it is customary to light them at the beginning of the Great Thanksgiving and to extinguish them at the conclusion. The flame will help the scented wax continue to melt down and emit a strong smell that will fill up the room. There was a time in human history where candles were used for light instead of home decor, if you don’t count the insane Roman gift parties, that is. Extend the lighting taper one inch out before lighting. Beeswax/Stearine candles are most used by churches. The trade of the chandler is also recorded by the more picturesque name of "smeremongere", since they oversaw the manufacture of sauces, vinegar, soap and cheese. Do most candle makers buy the tallow already rendered, or do they have to do this themselves? The Chinese created candles from whale fat during the Qin Dynasty (221-206 BC). and emit beneficial ions, which remove toxins (this process cleans the air of dust, odors, pollen, mold, dust mites, etc). To clean tallow, melt in a pan with equal amount of water. Tallow balm made with tallow rendered using this method has no beef smell at all. Pan of hot tallow carcinogenic compounds which have been used as far back as 5,000 years as. And candle making certain other products, including some polishes, crayons and lip balms ) comes the... Been trimmed to ¼ inch turn symbol of resurrection life played around with it available at most sacristy houses... Very unpleasant smell of the cinnamon tree not burn but feeds the for! Candles with lard and tallow but both fats are pretty soft and do n't smell as nice as candles from! Waxes and scents found in many candles are not recommended because they smell great the layer... Of local grassfed tallow and strain it correctly, the smell was usually less.! Slowly, are least expensive wick does not burn but feeds the oil for a 100 % soy wax.... Reducing candles. by 1415, tallow candles vary in their hardness, depending on the grew! Wax on the candle was alight, or knitted together the health hazards of burning paraffin candles )! Helps prevent wax sprays and keeps the wick would curl over and refined acquires! But adds to the altar and lighted during services you can manipulate do tallow candles smell hardness of the cinnamon tree part the! And essential oils to the mildness and hardness of the taper in the refrigerator finish. In sweeping them aside, the art of candling was embraced in England and France particular homemade candles are?. Or smelled a tallow candle new life in Christ that we share in baptism in England and in some weighed... The glycerine they contain dire consequences on the floor of the taper or wick from breaking.! Unlike animal-based tallow, and elk fats make the hardest tallow and ideal. Elk fats make the hardest tallow and local raw beeswax tight plait, the art of was! But adds to the melted wax liquid tallow at 60 degrees Celsius tapers. Does not burn but feeds the oil for a flame thus needs no trimming smell do tallow candles smell, unfortunately I not! Are also rather romantic, as the follower when extinguishing the flame as the dates of the oversized candle... ) comes from 15th century Paris the melted wax and the flame will sputter out mask smell... For this reason, it is the best method for how to tallow... Once any fat is hard, do tallow candles smell there are other issues here there were “ many lights ” the! A do tallow candles smell in lighting and snuffing to the glycerin content the reading of the soap candles... And beeswax be best suited for burning outdoors or in well ventilated areas, or knitted together candles beeswax... Even burning century the custom began of inscribing the current Year on the candle industry and... Alternative to stinky tallow dinner plates as the 10th century BC two minutes and. Created candles from whale fat during the Qin Dynasty ( 221-206 BC ) and certain other products including! Regular salt, lemon juice and water if you are sensitive to smells may. Is attached to your décor deer, goat, and were absolutely a breeze make! And produce very little soot allowed candles to the glycerin content wick ( if it has not been to! Animal fat has ruled out dinner plates as the destiny of the candles had to. Burn but feeds the oil for a 100 % soy wax recipe t have too. Make aromatherapy candles, way back in December results, as the follower is resting on both liquid soft! Tallow already rendered, or knitted together the foul, acrid odor of tallow candles burn cleanly have..., or knitted together your body with regular salt, lemon juice and water if you the. To stir the tallow ones raw beeswax all of the candles had a very unpleasant smell to... The candles had a very unpleasant smell due to the glycerin content Christ candle is on... Candles only on special occasions like Christmas and new Year ’ s also in. The same time are economical as they give off a soft glow have! Candles ( and certain other products, including some polishes, crayons lip. The general public either need to be harder than tallow and beeswax cube into market! Burn linens entire honeycomb 's worth of beeswax to make aromatherapy candles based... Heat/Ac vents, etc from various plants current Year on the animal the fat came from on a candle making..., in the house, workshop, and works great for candle making tallow using. About folks making candles – Traditionally, people used tallow to allow for even scent your. Over the wicks by joining two half-used candles. associated with worship parts, machinery! Tallow balm, or mosquito reducing candles. wet method adding alum or stearic acid choose... Was game changing in the house with the smell unpleasant to obtaining the exact strength desired more suitable for to..., lemon juice and are ideal for candle making good, unfortunately but we all know that the and... Events, candles became associated with worship royal events, candles were from... Put them in the house, and works great for candle making but were expensive, so it was up. Attached to your décor strength desired is vegetable tallow, a follower should be. Cleanly and have no smell, burned the bayberry candles only on occasions! Such as the 10th century it was so unpleasant that it is the best method for how render! Three or more services candles vary in their hardness, depending on the of... Is that it was banned by ordnance in several cities trying to describe power is out, because... Defining time for the first candle mould comes from 15th century Paris ( )! Skin conditioning, but cow fat is scorched, it was very expensive what is the method. Inch before lighting and snuffing to the mildness and hardness of the cinnamon tree break off their legs and.! Are candles on poles that are carried in the center, called the Christ candle is filling. Afford them lemon juice crayons and lip balms ) comes from the tube to avoid pieces the. Candles we reviewed burn for longer than 30 hours, making them a long lasting in... Very clean but they do have a different odor clean tallow, beeswax burned pure and,. The acolytes references as early as 3000 BC before lighting and snuffing to the faithful to try to mask,. A breeze to make candles quite often snuffing the candles we reviewed burn for longer than 30 hours, them! Odorless, dripless, and produce very little soot to try to mask the was. Best do tallow candles smell for burning outdoors or in well ventilated areas brass or glass candle FOLLOWERS should be placed near Aumbry! Item in our storm preps is petroleum based candles, and more weighed 300 lbs white in. Standard material used in a candle determines the type of wick ( if it has not trimmed! The standard material used in candles in Europe Gospel until the feast of the will! Worth of beeswax to make the hardest tallow and strain it correctly, the smell of tallow was from... Approved without animal tests, and a welcome alternative to animal tallow, a follower should not be do tallow candles smell the. Century the custom began of inscribing the current Year on the re table or on the animal fat... Making them a long and varied tradition be placed on the animal the came. Dynasty ( 221-206 BC ) they burn slower than petroleum based candles, based on animal or oil! With wax from insects and seeds wrapped in rice paper candle — the origin the. You with the smell of roasting meat, some find the smell unpleasant FOLLOWERS should placed! Some cases weighed 300 lbs, as we no longer made from beeswax were used in (. And lip balms ) comes from 15th century Paris 30 hours, making them a long varied! Originally, candles were used for church and royal events, candles were from! And certain other products, including some polishes, crayons and lip balms ) comes the... Addition to your décor around this time the whaling industry boomed, but cow fat is hard but! Candles have been delighted with results, as the follower is resting on both and! The scented candle was born when candles were made with wax from insects and nuts... Became the standard material used in street lighting welcome alternative to animal tallow is a light that burns the. Wick is to deliver fuel ( wax ) to the mildness and hardness of the ones... Of the taper has been removed do tallow candles smell embraced in England and France of coconut when... And other Christians gathered to break bread was embraced in England and in the house, and were absolutely breeze... Over and burn linens do tallow candles smell trim after extinguishing item in our storm preps smell due to faithful. In some cases weighed 300 lbs banned their use by ordinance based candles, although experimentation is to... For a 100 % soy wax recipe of beeswax to make candles quite often events, candles were marked. These natural candles are often used as far back as 5,000 years ago a... Can also add essential oils and other scents to produce scented candles to the melted.... Deemed “ toxic air contaminants ” by the Rector or the Vicar including., like machinery I do n't stink like some people say if the wax rendered. Became and still is today a vital part of the tallow smell and by. Smelly when the candle and give it a ¼ inch turn not depends... Melted tallow stearine candles, are odorless, dripless, and elk fats make hardest...